EXPLAINER

Reviving Ocean Health through Regional Cooperation

Destruction of ocean ecosystems can result in less catch. Photo credit: ADB.
Destruction of ocean ecosystems can result in less catch. Photo credit: ADB.

Published: 03 February 2021

Regional cooperation and integration efforts on marine life conservation can be improved through strengthened governance and financial sustainability.

Introduction

Oceans have provided food and livelihood to people in Asia and the Pacific for centuries. Coastal populations have grown and benefited from shipping, coastal and marine tourism, and natural resources. However, pollution, habitat loss, species loss, climate change, and unsustainable development have threatened ocean ecosystems. Challenges and threats to ocean health in one place can have a negative ripple effect across the region.

The rise of illegal fishing, plastic and infectious medical waste, harmful activities during the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic underscores the importance of international and regional cooperation in monitoring and protecting the oceans. Addressing transboundary challenges to ocean health and productivity requires coordinated implementation of best practices, good governance, and enforcement of international agreements among countries, international organizations, and other partners in the region.

This article is based on the chapter “Regional Cooperation and Integration for Ocean Health and a Sustainable Blue Economy” in the book ­­­Future of Regional Integration in Asia and the Pacific published by the Asian Development Bank (ADB). It takes a closer look at initiatives in regional cooperation and identifies ways these can be strengthened to efficiently address current and emerging challenges to ocean ecosystems.

What benefits do the oceans provide to Asia and the Pacific?

Oceans provide vital goods and services. They produce more than half of the oxygen in the atmosphere, regulate the climate, provide energy sources, and provide pharmaceutical resources. Many people in developing countries derive their livelihood from oceans, which significantly contributes to their countries’ gross domestic product (GDP). As much as 13% of Indonesia’s and 19% of Viet Nam’s GDP come from the oceans. The tourism, fisheries, and shipping industries form the foundation of the region’s blue economy, estimated to be between $3 trillion to $6 trillion globally.

Shipping and other maritime transport links provide important connections between and among countries in the region, widening the markets of local producers, creating employment, and generating income. The largest shipbuilding economies in the world are in Asia: People’s Republic of China, Japan, and the Republic of Korea. They build 80% of the world’s ships (in terms of compensated gross tons) and dominate the global market for bulkers, tankers, and containerships.

What are the major threats and impacts facing the region’s oceans?

Marine pollution and oil spills are two of the major threats to ocean ecosystems in the region. Nonpoint source pollution, solid waste and untreated wastewater, shipping, and urban activities adversely affect ocean health. Nonpoint source pollution comes from diffuse sources, such as excess fertilizers, insecticides, oil, grease, sediment, and toxic chemicals from agricultural, urban, and residential areas. About 49% of oil spills come from operational discharges and accidental spills from ships and land-based sources, while other sources are from natural seeping and oil extraction.

Overexploitation, increasing coastal populations and developments, and climate change also threaten ocean health. The destruction of mangroves and coral reefs are endangering coastal areas, reducing fish stocks, and releasing massive amounts of carbon dioxide (CO2) and greenhouse gases (GHGs) into the atmosphere and ocean. Increasing CO2 and other GHG emissions from human activities have contributed to higher ocean temperatures, increased frequency, and severity of extreme weather events, and rise in sea levels. Warming waters have caused mass die-offs of marine life and shifted species distribution. The impacts of climate change threaten ocean-dependent livelihoods and communities at risk.

Other threats to ocean ecosystems are i) threat of extinction of migratory marine species; ii) alien invasive species; iii) overfishing; iv) safety and security issues in maritime shipping; and v) COVID-19.

During the pandemic,  illegal, unreported, and unregulated fishing has risen as governments focused on the health crisis instead of enforcement.  The pandemic has also affected businesses and livelihoods that depend on the oceans. These include tourism, shipping, fisheries, offshore renewables, and aquaculture. As a result, fish and seafood exports could drop by a third, while cargo trade could dip by 10%.

How does regional cooperation help improve ocean health?

Through regional cooperation and integration, countries can develop shared goals and priorities, and create clear and consistent standards and mechanisms for funding requirements. It is critical to achieving the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), which require a multi-sector, multi-stakeholder, collaborative approach, particularly for SDG 14: Life Below Water.

Cooperation also helps the blue economy grow by building stronger institutions and closer trade integration and stronger financial links. Reducing or removing barriers at the border increases trade in goods and services, cross-border investment, labor mobility, and technology transfer to create a larger, regionally integrated market and more efficient supply chains. Regional cooperation stimulates economic growth in the shipping, fisheries, and tourism sectors; and helps effectively deal with challenges caused by increasing economic interdependence, such as the spread of contagious diseases and marine plastic pollution.

To improve regional initiatives on ocean-related transboundary issues in national and international waters, numerous intergovernmental organizations, agreements, and programs have been created. The table below shows a diverse sample of various mechanisms and governance structures, as well as selected initiatives, that are important regionally and can play an increasingly larger role in improving ocean health and the blue economy.

Table 1. Regional Cooperation and Integration Initiatives in Asia and the Pacific

Initiative Brief Description
ASEAN Working Group on Coastal and Marine Environments Aims to ensure ASEAN’s coastal and marine environments are sustainably managed; its unique ecosystems, pristine areas and species are protected; economic activities are sustainably managed; and public awareness of the coastal and marine environment increased
Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation Oceans and Fisheries Working Group Established to facilitate free trade and promote aquaculture and the sustainable use of fisheries, marine ecosystem resources, and related goods and services
Bay of Bengal Programme Inter-Governmental Organization Mandated to enhance cooperation among its member countries and other countries and organizations in the region and provide technical and management advisory services for sustainable coastal fisheries development and management in the Bay of Bengal region
Brunei Darussalam-Indonesia-Malaysia-Philippines East ASEAN Growth Area Cooperation initiative established in 1994 to accelerate the socioeconomic development of less-developed, marginalized, and geographically-remote areas within these four countries
Coordinating Body on the Seas of East Asia Intergovernmental organization that supports the development and protection of the marine environment and coastal areas of East Asian Seas
Coral Triangle Initiative on Coral Reefs, Fisheries, and Food Security

Formal intergovernmental partnership that aims to protect the region’s valuable economic and environmental assets through regional cooperation

Indonesia-Malaysia-Thailand Growth Triangle Sub-regional framework established to accelerate economic cooperation and integration among selected states and provinces in the three countries
Micronesia Challenge Multi-jurisdiction commitment to preserve the natural resources that Pacific traditions, cultures and livelihoods depend on
Northwest Pacific Action Plan Intergovernmental organization that was adopted by the People’s Republic of China, Japan, the Republic of Korea, and the Russian Federation in 1994 to achieve the goal of wise use, development, and management of the coastal and marine environment
Office of the Pacific Ocean Commissioner Established within the Pacific Islands Forum Secretariat in 2014 and is the highest regional Pacific entity mandated to lead on oceans matters
Parties to the Nauru Agreement Subregional fisheries agreement that has implemented many conservation measures that were the first of their kind, such as closing areas of the high seas to fishing
Partnerships in Environmental Management for the Seas of East Asia Intergovernmental organization that fosters and sustains healthy and resilient coasts and oceans, communities, and economies across the Seas of East Asia through integrated management solutions and partnerships
Regional fisheries management organizations Made up of countries that share a practical and/or financial interest in managing and conserving fish stocks in a particular area
Secretariat of the Pacific Regional Environment Programme Regional organization with 21 Pacific island member countries and territories and five developed country members with a mandate to promote cooperation in the Pacific region for environmental protection and sustainable development
South Asia Cooperative Environment Programme Inter-governmental organization established to promote and support protection, management, and enhancement of the environment and sustainable development of the region
South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation Intergovernmental organization dedicated to economic, technological, social, and cultural development, with an emphasis on collective self-reliance

What are the success areas of these initiatives?

A review of the selected regional organizations and programs showed similarities in their successes and lessons learned. The main recurring success areas, particularly in governance, knowledge, and capacity building, are the following:

Governance

  • Established mechanisms for cooperation and collaboration between member states.
  • Created synergy to improve governance and implement management programs.
  • Identified common priorities and provided a regional framework for cooperation.
  • Contributed to sub-regional economic integration.
  • Brought together stakeholders to create dialogue around ocean issues.
  • Inspired similar regional island commitments.

Knowledge and Capacity Building

  • Built on lessons from related initiatives and used partnerships to bring in expertise and knowledge.
  • “Oceans Champions” provided high-level advocacy and attention to priority areas, decisions, and processes, as well as, improved cooperation, coordination and collaboration.
  • Facilitated information exchange, built institutional capacity, and strengthened regional policy dialogue.
  • Raised awareness.
  • Improved science-to-management decision-making.

What lessons can be learned to improve regional cooperation and integration initiatives?

Effective regional governance requires the following: i) multiple and mutually reinforcing objectives that address environmental, economic, and social aspects of sustainability; ii) a strong secretariat to provide a central point of coordination; iii) a decentralized structure; iv) increased transparency, accountability, and public participation; v) and stakeholder engagement.

For effective national and local governance, these are needed: i) focus on addressing local and national issues, with regional collaboration as a secondary step; ii) integrate regional priorities with national priorities; iii) strengthen national government systems and ownership; iv) fill infrastructure gaps, provide an enabling policy and regulatory environment, and resolve issues such as cross-border trade; v) local government participation in regional strategy development; and vii) create a conducive business environment through incentives and information on potential regional markets.

Essential for knowledge and capacity building are: i) sharing of knowledge and lessons learned at the national and regional levels, with solutions adapted to local conditions; ii) improved management systems; and iii) increase decision makers’ understanding and motivation to act through field trips.

For finance, the need is to i) mobilize financial resources, such as donations and endowments; ii) raise awareness of politicians and citizens for them to prioritize and publicly support conservation efforts; iii) diversify financing sources to lower risk, such as tourism taxes, debt swaps, and revenues from fishing licenses; and iv) seek financing partners by encouraging contributions from major donors and governments.

How can regional efforts be strengthened?

Many regional initiatives established to address threats to marine ecosystems have been successful and impactful. However, they faced numerous challenges. Enforcing regulations across huge areas of open ocean and management of international waters can be difficult. Also, most entities struggled with regional, national, and local governance, and financial sustainability.

Recommendations to make these organizations and programs more effective and efficient are as follows:

  • Promote implementation and enforcement of multilateral agreements.
  • Improve institutional capacity of regional coordination entities while raising their profile and support from key national decision-makers.
  • Strengthen and institutionalize coordination mechanisms between regional cooperation and integration initiatives.
  • Improve transparency and strengthen relationships with stakeholders.
  • Establish inclusive and resilient value chains.
  • Initiate regional dialogue among governments and the global and regional shipping industry.
  • Develop and implement effective national policies and frameworks.
  • Establish regional data sharing systems to track SDG progress and improve management of ocean resources.
  • Raise public awareness and accelerate cooperation among ocean stakeholders.

Asia and the Pacific have greatly benefitted from regional cooperation and integration through strengthened economies, stronger country connections, and the establishment of shared goals and priorities. The COVID-19 pandemic calls for stronger cooperation and presents an opportunity for countries, regions, and sub-regions to redesign their economies for a joint recovery toward a sustainable green and blue future.

Resources

A. Hudson. 2020. The Ocean and COVID-19. UNDP. 8 June.

Asian Development Bank. ADB’s Work in Regional Cooperation and Integration.

DF. Anwar. 2006. Resource Issues and Ocean Governance in Asia Pacific: An Indonesian Perspective. Contemporary Southeast Asia. 28 (3) pp. 466-489.

E. Sanford et al.  2019. Widespread Shifts in the Coastal Biota of Northern California during the 2014-2016 Marine Heatwaves. Scientific Reports. 9 (4216).

G. Solano and C. Torchia. 260 Chinese Boats Fish Near Galapagos; Ecuador on Alert. The Washington Post. 31 July.

K. Gourdon and C. Steidl. 2019. Global Value Chains and the Shipbuilding Industry. OECD Science, Technology and Industry Working Papers, No. 2019/08. Paris: OECD Publishing.

L. Pagkalinawan, A. Oposa, and E. McGovern. 2021. Regional Cooperation and Integration for Ocean Health and a Sustainable Blue Economy. In B. Susantono and C. Park, eds. ­­­Future of Regional Integration in Asia and the Pacific. Manila: Asian Development Bank.

National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Office of Response and Restoration. 2015. How Does Oil Get Into the Ocean?

OECD. 2016. The Ocean Economy to 2030. Paris: OECD Publishing and UNCTAD. Oceans Economy and Fisheries.

United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific. 2020. Changing Sails: Accelerating Regional Actions for Sustainable Oceans in Asia and the Pacific. Bangkok: UN.

United States Environmental Protection Agency. Basic Information about Nonpoint Source (NPS) Pollution.

Ask the Experts

  • Lisa Kircher Pagkalinawan
    Senior Environment Specialist, Asian Development Bank

    Lisa Kircher Pagkalinawan is a senior environmental expert with over 28 years of experience in the Philippines and other Asian countries. She is currently a consultant working on ocean health with the Environment Thematic Group at the Asian Development Bank. She is a certified Qualified Environmental Professional and has a master’s degree in environmental management from Yale University.

  • Anna Oposa
    Ocean Health Partnerships Specialist, Asian Development Bank and Executive Director, Save Philippine Seas

    Anna Oposa is the executive director of Save Philippine Seas, a movement to protect the Philippines' coastal and marine resources by mobilizing seatizen-led initiatives toward collective action and behavior change. She is currently a consultant working on ocean health with the Environment Thematic Group at the Asian Development Bank and has also worked on youth-related projects at the bank.

  • Eva McGovern
    Knowledge Management, Communications and Events Specialist, Asian Development Bank

    Eva McGovern has nearly 20 years of experience in knowledge management, strategic communications, editing, writing, curating, programming, project management, and event management. She is currently a consultant working on ocean health with the Environment Thematic Group at the Asian Development Bank. She has worked in the United Kingdom and across Southeast Asia.

  • Asian Development Bank (ADB)

    The Asian Development Bank is committed to achieving a prosperous, inclusive, resilient, and sustainable Asia and the Pacific, while sustaining its efforts to eradicate extreme poverty. Established in 1966, it is owned by 68 members—49 from the region. Its main instruments for helping its developing member countries are policy dialogue, loans, equity investments, guarantees, grants, and technical assistance.

    Follow Asian Development Bank (ADB) on

Leave your question or comment in the section below:






Disclaimer

The views expressed on this website are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Asian Development Bank (ADB) or its Board of Governors or the governments they represent. ADB does not guarantee the accuracy of the data included in this publication and accepts no responsibility for any consequence of their use. By making any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area, or by using the term “country” in this document, ADB does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area.




Was this article useful?