CASE STUDY

Sorsogon City: Options for Developing a New Landfill

Technical assistance was provided to five municipalities in Asia, including Sorsogon City, to upgrade their 10-year solid waste management plans. Photo credit: ADB.
Technical assistance was provided to five municipalities in Asia, including Sorsogon City, to upgrade their 10-year solid waste management plans. Photo credit: ADB.

Sorsogon City in the Philippines is investigating options for upgrading its open dumpsites to a properly managed landfill.

Overview

Sorsogon City in the Philippines is in urgent need of a new well-operated controlled disposal facility. The city provides the solid waste management service rather than a private operator. Services range from waste collection to disposal and includes information, education, and communication campaigns to reduce waste. One of the city’s two dumps is closed, and the second is poorly operated and generates landfill leachate with associated environmental and public health risks.

The Asian Development Bank (ADB) provided technical assistance on mainstreaming solid waste management to Sorsogon City and four other cities in Asia. Key assistance was reviewing current activities and upgrading 10-year SWM plans to improve the overall system as well as delivering one tailored project for each city. Issues covered were waste avoidance, minimization, and recycling; waste haulage and disposal; and information, education and communication campaigns.

After consulting stakeholders, the project team and the Sorsogon City developed and agreed on an enhanced 10-year integrated solid waste management plan with a range of new activities. Due to strong interest from city, the project team conducted a pre-feasibility study into the design and cost of a controlled landfill facility based on the site topography and area available.


Project information


Project snapshot

  • April 2015: Project start
  • March 2017: Project end
  • US$ 1.4 million: Total cost of technical assistance over 2 years
  • Financing
  • Others
    • Sorsogon City, City Environment and Natural Resources Office: Stakeholders

Challenges

The project identified six significant challenges for solid waste management in Sorsogon municipality.

One is the need to facilitate a shift from non-environment friendly, non-reusable packaging into environment-friendly and degradable packaging. This should be combined with the second challenge of implementing an intensified and continuous information, education, and communication campaign on waste segregation at source. 

The third challenge is to strengthen the capability of barangays, the local adminsitration units within the city, to collect and process waste generated within their respective areas of jurisdiction.

Fourth is to improve the Sorsogon City government’s waste collection efficiency and waste processing capability.

The fifth challenge is to upgrade the city’s two open uncontrolled dumpsites, Buenavista Dumpsite and the Bato Dumpsite, to controlled landfill standards.

Finally, the sixth is to develop the new landfill site at Buenavista, using private contractors to design, construct, and operate it, and to provide the required skills, experience, and training.

Solutions

As the city is in urgent need of a disposal facility to complete its solid waste management facilities, the project provided assistance in the preliminary design and costing of a controlled landfill facility, based on the site topography and area available. The project prepared a pre-feasibility study of the facility and the projected cost of the facility is 19.5 million pesos.

In a November 2016 workshop, private service providers were invited to a meeting with city officers to discuss possible assistance to establish and operate a controlled landfill facility through a public-private partnership mechanism.

The project team advised the City Environment and Natural Resources Office to conduct bulk density measurement of the waste and use the data to adjust the waste assessment and characterization study values and their corresponding projections.

The project team reviewed, evaluated, and upgraded Sorsogon City’s10-year solid waste management plan, which was upgraded with changes and corrections based on the waste characterization data and projections. The updated plan was made more comprehensive based on the solid waste management plan template of ADB.

Proposed actions in the short term include looking at a range of options for diverting waste from disposal, conducting training on ways to optimize waste collection, and using correct methods of operation and maintenance of the disposal system. In the longer term, actions include rehabilitation of the dump sites and acquisition of expansion site of the controlled landfill.

Projected Capital Expenditure for Landfill Development

CAPEX financed by operator
(excluded from the DBO)
Unit Number US$ Description
Landfill Operating Equipment
Dozer (Caterpillar D6 or equivalent with landfill blade) Item 1 $250,000 D6 size assumed and high quality supplier
Excavator/ end Loader - assume Caterpillar D200 or equivalent Item 1 $100,000 For loading cover soil and any waste to be relocated. Drain cleanouts.
10 wheeler tipping dump truck Item 1 $60,000 New one just purchased
8,000-liter Water tank with pump Item 1 $12,000 For watering gravel roads and fire control. Lifted onto the back of the 10 wheel tip truck when required. Also used for fire control if required.
Total     $422,000  

CAPEX = Capital expenditure, DBO = Design-build-operate, US$ = US dollar

CAPEX Items (Additional Information for Equipment)
Equipment years depreciation 7
Civil works years depreciation na
Annual depreciation equipment US$ 60,286
Annual depreciation equipment PhP million 3

CAPEX = Capital expenditure, PhP = Philippine peso, US$ = US dollar

CAPEX included in the DBO contract
Item Unit Value
Total CAPEX in DB structure US$ 568,350
Total CAPEX in DB structure Php million 26
Years repayment DB to operator years 2
Annual payment DB to operator US$ 324,076
Annual payment DB to operator Php million 15

CAPEX = Capital expenditure, DBO = Design-build-operate, PhP = Philippine peso, US$ = US dollar

Results

Identification of a new landfill site and project planning by Sorsogon City were well timed with the development of the pre-feasibility study, which proposed outsourcing the design, building, and long-term operation of the new landfill. In addition, the private contract would encompass the remediation of the closed Buenavista dumping site and the operating Bato site.

Meetings between city officials and private contractors in November 2016 confirmed there is a growing pool of experienced landfill contractor operators in the Philippines.  The private sector showed considerable interest. The potential for an operating contract to be long term (10 years or more) did not deter them even when taking into account that in the Philippines, usual terms are 1 to 2 years post completion.

A public-private partnership would bring mutual benefit because the private sector will bring multi-project experience of implementing and operating successful landfill projects in the Philippines. Financial contractual incentives tied to detailed objective performance standards would motivate their performance.

The pre-feasibility study highlights some key technical objectives of a design-build-operate, public-private partnership contract with particular emphasis on the need to correctly shape and compact the landfill for leachate and stormwater management and to construct and maintain a relatively impermeable basal liner of compacted clay.

While Sorsogon City officials would optimally seek project funding for all or most of the project through grants, it is possible to borrow funds on a long-term basis for at least a major portion of the capital cost. Contractors expressed interest in funding project costs, but their options would typically carry a much higher borrowing cost than if the city borrows the money.

The city recognizes that it would have to repay either bank loans or contractor investment tariffs from general fund revenues rather than from solid waste net revenues. This leads to important conclusions that solid waste revenues should be significantly increased and annual debt payment amounts kept within limits so as not to compete with other urgent city needs.

Lessons

Sorsogon City’s strong commitment to improve solid waste management was critical to implementing the project successfully. The stable political environment allowed decisions to be made in a timely and predictable manner.

The integrated solid waste management plan provided under the project developed a comprehensive plan of action for the city and allowed priorities to be set despite a budget-stressed environment.

Developing a close working relationship with the city officials allowed the team to identify the need for external technical support in developing the controlled landfill, and garnered the officials’ support to approach and commit to using the private sector.

The limited ability of the city to internally finance the landfill project is the driving force for Sorsogon City to aggressively and creatively source possible funding assistance. They are seeking funds from the national government and from other financial institutions, including official development assistance using the pre-feasibility study provided by the project team as a basis for these requests.

Approaching the private sector for technical support can also allow the upfront capital costs to be devolved to the private developer and to be repaid either as payment milestones (connected with physical works progress) or as part of the agreed tariff over a longer term.

Resources

Asian Development Bank. 2017. Integrated Solid Waste Management for Local Governments: A Practical Guide. Mandaluyong City.

Asian Development Bank. Regional Capacity Development Technical Assistance on Mainstreaming Solid Waste Management in Asia

Related links

Summary: Improving Waste Management - Solutions from Five Asian Cities

Case Study: Buriram - The Economics of Refuse Derived Fuel Production

Case Study: Mahasarakham - Privatizing Landfill Operations

Case Study: Mandalay City - Outsourcing Waste Collection Services

Case Study: Quezon City: Making Waste Management a Rewarding Investment

 

   Last updated: March 2017

 

Meet the experts

  • Lyndsay Chapple
    Environmental engineering consultant

    Lyndsay Chapple has worked in solid waste management for more than 3 decades. His expertise covers all aspects of solid waste management, ranging from environmental assessments to detailed design of facilities. His passion is developing site-specific solutions that are pragmatic and sustainable.

    Follow Lyndsay Chapple on

  • Andrew McIntyre
    Senior Urban Development Specialist, Sustainable Development and Climate Change Department, Asian Development Bank

    Andrew McIntyre leads ADB’s Future Cities Program, operationalizing a One ADB approach to better engage with Asian cities over  the long term, by facilitating cross-sectoral knowledge and financing partners, broadening project pipelines and ensuring integrated results. Andrew's career spans 32 years, 60 projects and in 35 ADB developing member countries.

    Follow Andrew McIntyre on




Disclaimer

The views expressed in these articles are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Asian Development Bank, its management, its Board of Directors, or its members.




Was this article useful?